Add yet another skill to Alexa's repertoire: staunch defense of the First Amendment.
Amazon is Dear Utol (2025): My Bilmoko GF Episode 34holding firm and refusing to hand over voice and transcription data recorded by an Echo speaker to prosecutors in Arkansas as part of a murder trial.
Amazon maintains the authorities haven't clearly established that the investigation is more important than a customer's privacy rights, according to an AP report, and claims the recorded data and Alexa's responses are protected under the First Amendment.
Last week, the company filed a 91-page motion (obtained by Ars Technica) with the Benton County Circuit Court to kill the search warrant.
Police first issued a warrant for the data back in December, hoping to gain insight on the hours leading up to the death of Victor Collins in November 2015. The owner of the Echo speaker, James Andrew Bates, pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder.
At that point, an Amazon spokesperson told Mashable, "Amazon will not release customer information without a valid and binding legal demand properly served on us. Amazon objects to overbroad or otherwise inappropriate demands as a matter of course." Amazon reps gave the AP the same statement yesterday after filing the motion.
Specifically, the motion states, "The recordings stored by Amazon for a subscriber’s Echo device will usually be both (1) the user’s speech, in the form of a request for information from Alexa, and (2) a transcript or depiction of the Alexa Voice Service response conveying the information it determines would be most responsive to the user’s query. Both types of information are protected speech under the First Amendment.”
In refusing to hand over the recorded data, Amazon is sticking to its guns. The company said prosecutors must prove the information isn't available elsewhere before seizing the recorded data, and also requests that the court reviews it before the prosecutors to be sure that it's actually relevant to the case at hand.
The case is similar to Apple's legal battle with the FBI in California following the San Bernardino shootings. After the FBI demanded that Apple unlock the shooter's phone, the company refused, and the two were at a stalemate until the FBI found a different way into the device.
Topics Amazon Amazon Alexa Amazon Echo
There's a crystal clear Kanye West burn hiding in Taylor Swift's new songTaylor Swift album 'Reputation' coming in NovemberGame of Thrones: Jon Snow may be King in the North, but he's a bad leaderWoman hands out 'boy poison' note about embracing femininity at workPeople are memeing the hell out of Taylor Swift's new album coverBurger King Russia apparently invented its own silly digital currency called WhoppercoinTaylor Swift's 'Look What You Made Me Do' video: Watch previewTaylor Swift fans discovered her new album details before she could unveil them herselfOld Taylor Swift is dead. May New Taylor Swift forever reign in terrorWhy are they called the 'dog days' of summer?Google introduces tool to help users test for depressionYou can now set up a 360 photo as your Facebook coverTransparent Nintendo Switch case is a nod to the '90sShania Twain reveals why Brad Pitt didn't impress her muchTaylor Swift's 'Reputation': With new album, singer is about to get realThe dark side of optimism: How the trait you value most could be ruining youPeople are memeing the hell out of Taylor Swift's new album coverMark Zuckerberg confirms Facebook will add subscriptions for publishers, not take a cutHow will Jon Snow find out about his parents on 'Game of Thrones'?Tom Cruise's fake butt is the internet's newest conspiracy theory NYT Connections Sports Edition hints and answers for June 22: Tips to solve Connections #272 How to use YouTube Shopping: Tips from VidCon 2025 How TikTok helped Zay Dante launch his music career Cost Per Frame Analysis: The Best Graphics Cards in Mid 2025 Fluminense vs. Ulsan HD 2025 livestream: Watch Club World Cup for free Most Anticipated PC Games of 2025 How to make a hook in a TikTok video How CPUs are Designed and Built Essential Apps to Install on your Windows PC or Mac Content creation tools: How Brooke Ashley Hall uses an iPhone and drone to create viral content NBA livestream 2025: How to watch NBA for free Queen's Club Championships 2025 livestream: How to watch Queens Tennis for free Jools Lebron, Ruba Wilson, and more come together to discuss being LGBTQ creators. Using ChatGPT to write essays may harm critical thinking, MIT study finds Moon phase today explained: What the moon will look like on June 22, 2025 British and Irish Lions vs. Argentina 2025 livestream: Watch Lions Tour for free Portugal vs. Netherlands 2025 livestream: Watch U21 Euro 2025 for free Mamelodi Sundowns vs. Borussia Dortmund 2025 livestream: Watch Club World Cup for free Creator Playbook: How V Spehar balances their work as a creator and journalist How to set up a Microsoft passkey before August deadline
1.5447s , 8204.8203125 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【Dear Utol (2025): My Bilmoko GF Episode 34】,Exquisite Information Network