Critics everywhere have Watch She is Hungry For Men Onlineslammed the latest Harry Potter spin-off, Fantastic Beasts:The Crimes of Grindelwald, as there's an absurd amount of confounding plot crammed into the 134-minute film.
Yet, the film carries a problematic canonical oversight, too: Minerva McGonagall briefly appears as a young-adult wizarding instructor at Hogwarts in 1927. The trouble is, according to Harry Potter lore, she wouldn't have even been born at that point.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
(Pottermore, for those who might not know, is the online portal for all things Harry Potter and Wizarding World. It features original writing from creator J.K. Rowling that is recognized as official canon.)
As Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling reveals in the original series, the famously strict Professor McGonagall first started teaching at the Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry in 1956, when she was a spry 21 years old.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
On Twitter, some have argued that this "Minerva McGonagall" may have actually been Professor McGonagall's witch mother. But this is almost certainly wrong. Mashable reviewed the original screenplay, which explicitly cites a "Minerva McGonagall" in the film. Minerva's mother was named "Isobel Ross," and later "Isobel McGonagall" after marrying the muggle Robert McGonagall.
SEE ALSO: What the shocking end reveal during 'Crimes of Grindelwald' means for the 'Fantastic Beasts' franchiseIsobel, notably, was also never a professor at Hogwarts. Fans have been pointing all of this out for days, since the first details about Grindelwaldstarted making their way online. Some see McGonagall's appearance as an error. Others think it's part of the plan, and there's more to be revealed.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
Rowling, who is credited for writing the Fantastic Beasts sequel script, couldn't slip this mistake past vigilant Potter fans. Perhaps such lapses won't occur in next installment of Fantastic Beasts, which this film largely existed to set up.
Rowling, who is very active on social media, hasn't yet weighed in on the issue of Professor McGonagall's age in The Crimes of Grindelwald.
Topics Harry Potter
Mastodon sees significant drop in users8 classic 'standThe best gadgets for a family trip: Make travel with kids easierThe real winner at the AMAs was Lizzo's tiny purseTwitter may soon charge brands $1000 to keep gold checkmark13 gifts for people with acid refluxWatching these Fox News hosts deflate while listening to Trump is oddly satisfyingDude pranks San Francisco by placing AirPod stickers all over the cityWordle today: Here's the answer, hints for February 4Are the Samsung Galaxy S23 colors really lavender and green?Every single 'Harry Potter' spell, ranked by usefulnessTwitter will have a free API tier for 'good' botsAre the Samsung Galaxy S23 colors really lavender and green?Someone hired Mark McGrath and Anthony Scaramucci to break up with their boyfriend on Cameo6 nightmareChrissy Teigen calls out Donald Trump Jr.'s suspiciously amazing book salesTrump's unexpected hospital trip has Twitter conspiracies in overdriveWatching these Fox News hosts deflate while listening to Trump is oddly satisfyingDominance and submission: a guide to Dom/sub dynamicsAll the tech companies laying off employees in 2023 Rudy Giuliani stumped when attempting to defend Donald Trump on 'Meet The Press' This eagle stuck in a car grille, but okay, is a metaphor for America during this election WeRateDogs is releasing a new card game where you can rate all the good pups The independent workforce is bigger than anyone thought Dictionary fact Trump just said he and his running mate disagree on a major issue Watch Tiffany Trump avoid her father's awkward big kiss 'Apex Legends' hits an impressive 10 million players Billy Bush suspended from NBC after release of Donald Trump audio Ivanka Trump tweets about pizza, remains silent on Donald Trump's leaked audio Victims reclaim their own narratives at Sundance 2019 NYPD to Google: Quit tracking drunk ‘I’m a gentleman’ says Trump, who also said he grabs women by the p*ssy Can Republicans dump Trump as their 2016 presidential candidate? Amazon releases suggestions for regulating facial recognition software Apple releases fix for disastrous group FaceTime bug '2 Dope Queens' Season 2 serves all the looks and laughs: Review LG's G8 will have a 3D selfie camera LOL, bye: Facebook’s teen meme project is dead before it was released 'Make Sydney late again' say thousands of Aussies in mass protest for nightlife
2.4611s , 10133.546875 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【Watch She is Hungry For Men Online】,Exquisite Information Network