If you’ve suffered through enough mediocre X-Menmovies to feel a general fatigue for any live action incarnations of Professor X and War Archiveshis lovable gang -- comics fan or not -- Legionis capable of changing your mind.
Legionhas all the ingredients for greatness: A promising cast, a wealth of well-regarded source source material from the X-Men comics, FargoTV series creator Noah Hawley pulling the strings as showrunner, and a home on FX, which struck creative gold with Fargoand is looking to repeat that success with a similar formula here.
The premiere episode, “Chapter 1,” signals that Fargo’s special sauce goes well on other dishes. An hour in and Legionalready feels like its own little universe, one in which you might find true love on the worst day of your life and suitcases are lime green as a matter of course.
Legionfollows David Haller (Downton Abbey’s Dan Stevens), a mutant truly in the X-Men tradition -- he possesses incredible powers that, for various reasons, he’s unable to harness. Specifically, David seems to be a powerful telepath, but has convinced himself he’s insane in order to survive in a world of aggressive normalization (in that way, at least, Legion’s reality is just like ours).
SEE ALSO: 'Legion' creator wants the show to prove itself before you call it an X-Men series"Chapter 1" covered a refreshing amount of that trope-laden ground. No, David, you’re not really crazy; yes, you have powers. And it will indeed be cathartic to watch you learn to wield them against men in ugly suits, or men wielding masks and assault rifles. That journey seems well underway by the time this episode’s credits triumphantly begin to roll.
That’s not what Legionis really about, though -- not currently, at least. In "Chapter 1," this X-Men show is entirely about nostalgia -- though crucially it’s David’s nostalgia, not the audience’s. An infant David is our first glimpse within, and through this opening montage the show says a lot with a little. David is happy, David grows up, David hears voices, David is unhappy, David hangs himself.
David is always yearning for that earlier time -- when his mother called to him, when he played in a field. His flashbacks are a constant in "Chapter 1." And at the end, after a climactic (if a little cheesy) trench warfare escape from someone’s probably-evil clutches, when it seems David’s world is finally about to open up, he thinks only of his time in the hospital. He senses a turning point, and his six years locked safely away take on the golden hue of fond remembrance. Anything is better than the confusing present and an uncertain future.
Clearly David has developed this coping mechanism across a lifetime of trying futilely to convince himself he’s mentally ill. And it’s downright incredible how effectively Legiongets this across in a single episode. Stevens’ unhinged performance -- his character seeming always on the edge of freaking out -- goes a long way. We know going into the show that David is a mutant, but Stevens convinces us he also really is at least partially crazy. And seeing this world through the frenetic lens of David’s mind will make you feel crazy too.
Fargo’s stylistic trappings are everywhere. Legionmay be set in the present (or maybe not -- its time period is left intentionally vague), but half its scenes, particularly those in the hospital and in David’s sister’s house, could have been plucked from a period piece set in the ‘60s or ‘70s. Modest cardigans, big collars and tweed abound. The episode opens to The Who’s “Happy Jack,” a song released in 1966.
There’s phenomenal use of music overall, the score never missing a beat even as it switches seamlessly to electronica; as well as exquisite slow-mo and carefully utilized color (pay attention any time red shows up).
Some of Fargo’s stars are present as well. Rachel Keller as Syd Barrett takes charge of any room or scene she enters, while Jean Smart’s Melanie Bird promises something great with an outstretched hand.
And Hawley’s penchant for wringing sarcastic drama from otherwise funny actors -- a la Key and Peele in Fargoseason 1 -- continues with Aubrey Plaza’s role as David’s voice-in-head companion Lenny Busker.
The connective tissue between Hawley’s past successes and Legioncan’t be ignored. If you liked Fargo, you will like Legion, whether or not you give a hoot about X-Menin general.
Perhaps most of all, it’s because of Hawley’s unique talent for injecting twisted levity into scenes bookended with tension and violence. “I’m insane, you idiot,” David explains wryly, seconds before a room’s worth of people get psychically microwaved (or something!). There’s even a damn dance number toward the end.
There’s so much promise in Legion’s first chapter. The show could have languished, drawing out David’s journey through the system, and it probably would have gotten away with it, because even the episode’s slow opening half is enthralling. But in the latter portion of the hour, it immediately answers half the questions it knew you already had, and poses many more.
SEE ALSO: Bryan Singer explains why the X-Men franchise is perfect for TVWhat's the nature of Syd’s power? Was the body-switch her doing or David's? Who is the hideous devil with the yellow eyes? Is David a reliable narrator? (No.) Maybe most importantly, or maybe least, what’s real and what isn’t in David’s world?
David may be partially crazy, but he isn’t stupid. He’s asking the same questions. And the people who’ve surrounded him so far have differing answers. Meanwhile Syd’s vehement and loving assurances at the end that she is, indeed, really real, might just have convinced me of the opposite. Anyone else notice, in the scene where she sneaks into David’s bed, that the camera never showed her entering the room?
Legionairs Wednesdays at 10 p.m. on FX.
Jamey Gambrell on Vladimir Sorokin by Nicole RudickContact by Adam GildersChris Adrian on ‘The Great Night’ by Sam MacLaughlinStaff Picks: Chad Harbach, The Mets, Masters of the Sob by The Paris ReviewThe Soloist: Jason Moran Live at A Gathering of Tribes by J. D. MitchellWell Preserved by Ian VolnerWill Self on ‘Walking to Hollywood’ by Jonathan GharraieContact by Adam GildersStaff Picks: Lawrence of Tell Halaf, Raging Nymphos by The Paris ReviewPostscript: Celebrating Sybille Bedford by Sylvia BrownriggNASA scientists reveal unsettling melting source on GreenlandGood Food Writing; Crazy People by Lorin SteinEmily Fragos on Emily Dickinson’s Letters by David O'NeillMy Manticore by Sadie SteinA Miniature Fascination by Sadie SteinMaira Kalman by Daisy AtterburyPoem: Pomme by Rachel Jamison WebsterPoem: Pomme by Rachel Jamison WebsterThe International by Richard BrodyWin Two Tickets to Arcadia by Peter Conroy Twitter is dragging Trump for this photo of his 'diverse' staff Google X's Loon internet balloon project announces a breakthrough Apple's war against you repairing your iPhone is pure corporate greed You may hate me but, you shouldn't get too excited about an *NSYNC reunion Tinder buys video app Wheel to make itself more like Snapchat McDonald's restaurants across the nation close for 'Day Without Immigrants' There's a reason why you feel like time is moving slower in Trump's America Revealed: What really happened to Star Wars' most hated character Hannah Hart's first project in new movie deal: An LGBTQ rom Ultimate bestie goes undercover to help friend on first date No, you shouldn't be allowed to fix your own phone, 'Right Apple TV might get 4K video streaming, but it'll still lag behind You'll actually want to watch these stop Donald Trump is basically Frank Costanza so it’s going to be Festivus all the time Dude defies physics and saves toddler from falling off a counter Police are mad about a 'Grand Theft Auto' mod and all the internet can do is LOL Apple patent alerts iPhone users when screen is cracked Facebook's new 'Trending Topics' update is here — now with less fake news Xiaomi India's Manu Kumar Jain promoted as global VP Beautiful photo strips capture the moment a man finds out he's going to be a dad
1.3911s , 10156.125 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【War Archives】,Exquisite Information Network